.png)
Every brand thinks it lost a customer to a competitor. Most lost them to indifference.
The customer didn't make a decision. No comparison was made, no alternative was chosen. The brand just became difficult to remember, and when the next purchase occasion came around, whoever was easier to find won.
That's where most Shopify customer retention strategies fail, not in the product or the price. In the gap between orders where the brand was silent and expected the customer to do the work.
The brands with strong retention strategies don't leave that gap open. Every touchpoint after the first purchase is an opportunity to make coming back feel obvious.
A loyalty program that rewards the second order. Email flows that feel like they were written for one person, not forwarded to ten thousand. A site that doesn't make a returning customer feel like a new one.
The brands that do all three are the ones people keep buying from. Not because they're necessarily the best option but because they're the easiest to come back to.
Five Specialists. One Clear Argument.
When Linh from the Flits team sat down with Samantha Thornton-Jones, Founder of Skyrocket, the conversation started from exactly that point. What makes a customer easy to keep?
Skyrocket is a certified Shopify Partner based in Auckland and Queenstown, New Zealand. A team of five senior specialists, with no account managers and no juniors, working with established NZ and Australian businesses on Shopify and Webflow builds. They describe themselves as commercially-led: every decision traceable back to what the site needs to achieve.
That framing matters when the conversation turns to retention, because Samantha's answers start from the same place. What is making this hard for the customer?
Linh from the Flits team sat down with Samantha as part of the Flits Agency Interview Series. Here's that conversation.
Why Most Shopify Customers Don't Come Back
The most common reason a customer doesn't return to a Shopify store isn't price or product. It's that the brand became easy to forget.
It sounds obvious when you say it out loud. But most retention conversations start with the email flow, the discount code, the winback sequence. They start downstream of the actual problem. Samantha starts upstream.
Q1: What’s one thing you wish more Shopify merchants understood about keeping customers coming back in 2026?
“Making it easy for customers is everything. If it’s hard to remember you exist and it’s like starting fresh every time, they are more likely to consider a competitor.”
The brand that solves that problem doesn’t need a winback campaign, because the customer never really left.
Knowing the problem is one thing. The question is what fixing it actually looks like.
How Shopify Loyalty Programs Improve Retention
The most reliable answer to the forgettability problem is making the second purchase feel rewarding before it happens. A Shopify loyalty program does that. Paired with email flows that feel personal rather than automated, it closes the gap between orders before the customer even notices it opened.
This is where Samantha's approach sits. Rather than chasing customers who’ve left, the focus should be on building infrastructure that makes leaving less likely.
Q2: How do you typically approach retention for your clients, especially after the first purchase?
“Loyalty programmes coupled with well refined, personal, email flows works incredibly well.”
Two things doing two jobs. The loyalty program gives the customer a reason to return that isn't a discount. The personal email flow makes sure they remember it exists. Together they do what most retention strategies try to do separately and fail at.
That combination has been working for a while. The tools shaping how it gets built, though, are changing and making it rapidly easier to execute.
What AI Is Changing About Shopify Customer Retention
AI’s most useful function in Shopify retention right now isn’t writing better emails. It’s making personalization practical at a scale that wasn’t possible two years ago.
For most brands, that used to mean segmenting by purchase history and hoping the logic held. Now the personalization layer is sharper; it adapts better. And for a small specialist team working across multiple clients, that matters.
Q3: How are you seeing AI change the way brands handle retention and re-engagement right now? Any tools or approaches you're particularly excited about?
“It's making it easy to personalize customer communication and offerings. As well as thinking of ways to approach retention that you might not have thought of previously.”
Her last point is particularly interesting. AI isn't just speeding up the existing playbook. It's also surfacing angles that weren't obvious from the data alone. Retention tactics that weren't even in the original brief, because the business hadn’t considered it, are now on the map.
What Good Shopify Returning Customer Rates Actually Look Like
Industry sources commonly place average ecommerce conversion rates at around 2.5% to 3%. When the site experience and retention mechanics are built around how customers actually shop, that number noticeably increases
Skyrocket's results across two very different clients show what that looks like in practice. Heritage Saunas is not a category where repeat purchase happens quickly or easily. A 4.6% enquiry conversion rate against a 2.7% industry benchmark doesn't happen because the emails were better.
Clean Collective is a brand where loyalty and conversion go hand in hand. A 103% conversion rate increase and 28% sales growth is the kind of number that needs a structural explanation, not a campaign one.
Q4: What kind of results have you helped clients achieve in terms of retention or repeat purchases?
“We have many clients with retention rates sitting widely higher than industry average. It's a testament to their brand, community, and the functionality of their website supporting that. For Heritage Saunas, we achieved a 4.6% enquiry conversion rate vs 2.7% industry benchmark. For Clean Collective, we achieved a 103% conversion rate increase and 28% sales growth.”
Brand, community, website functionality, in that order. The tools and flows behind the scenes are the required cherry on top.
What This Tells Us
- Heritage Saunas and Clean Collective have nothing in common on paper. One is a considered, high-value purchase. The other is a brand where community and repeat buying go hand in hand. The retention challenge in each is different. The answer in both was the same.
- Make it easier to come back than to go elsewhere.
- Retention is a friction problem. The customer who forgets you exist isn't a lost cause. They just weren't given enough reason to remember.
- A loyalty program gives them the reason. A refined and personal email flow keeps that reason visible. A site that recognises a returning customer treats them like one.
- Remove the friction, and the repeat purchase follows. Everything else is amplifying what's already there.
Are you a Shopify agency working on retention for your clients?
The Flits Agency Interview Series is open. If you're working on retention and have something worth saying, we're all ears.
